No thanks! I would like to know more about CHROMacademy

 Over 3000 E-Learning topics / 5000 Articles & Applications
 
HPLC Troubleshooting Guide – Peak Tailing

Tailing peaks create issues with resolution, quantitation (integration), and reproducibility.  Peak shape is often the controlling factor when optimizing complex separations, especially when components are present in very different concentrations.  The extent to which a peak is tailing can be assessed using Equation 1.

Figure 1: TF = (a) 1.24, (b) 1.42, (c) 1.58, and (d) overlay of a, b, and c.

When methods are designed a limit is usually set on the level of tailing that is acceptable.  If you work under regulatory guidelines this may be set by the governing body.  For in-house methods a reasonable guideline is TF ≤ 2.

How do you start troubleshooting a problem when it arises?  A great tool provided by CHROMacademy are our interactive HPLC (and GC) Troubleshooters.  Therefore, we are going to look at the top 5 causes of peak tailing provided by the HPLC Troubleshooter – these results have been ranked so are the most likely causes of peak tailing and should, therefore, be your first consideration when you are faced with this problem.  In total the Troubleshooter returns 25 possible causes of peak tailing, hence, this is often not a straightforward problem to fix.

1. Analyte/Stationary Phase Secondary Interactions

Unwanted secondary interactions between the analyte and stationary phase can lead to peak shape problems, typically peak tailing and loss of efficiency, which may ultimately lead to a loss of resolution and difficulty with peak integration.

The most common interaction is between polar or ionized analyte functional groups and un-capped (un-reacted) silanol groups on a silica stationary phase surface (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Interaction between a charged basic analyte and an acidic surface silanol group.

There are several ways to avoid peak tailing due to analyte/surface silanol interactions:

  1. Choose a column with reduced secondary surface silanol species (end-capped, hybrid, and/or type B silica would be suitable)
  2. Choose a suitable pH to minimize secondary interactions: at low pH (~2.5) silanol species are non-ionized and the degree of peak tailing will reduce, at this pH acidic species will be less ionized and, therefore, peak shape will improve. With basic species at low pH, most bases will be protonated (ionized) but the suppression of surface silanol species will mitigate the degree of peak tailing
  3. Increasing buffer concentration (> 20 mM) or swapping the counter ion for one which is more highly surface active may also help to mitigate the degree of peak tailing
  4. A more traditional method for controlling peak tailing is the use of a sacrificial base (such as triethylamine) in the mobile phase (0.05 M is typical) which is sterically small and charged at low pH and will preferentially interact with the surface silanol species
  5. Certain analytes may chelate with metal ions on the stationary phase surface (which may be included in the silica matrix or may have leached from the column internal surface or frit) – this secondary interaction will also affect peak shape and produce peak tailing

2. Incorrect/Non-Optimal Mobile Phase pH

Mobile phase pH affects retention of ionizable analytes and the selectivity of separations in reversed phase HPLC with some methods requiring a very precise pH to provide robust analyses.  Low pH tends to increase retention of acidic analytes and decrease retention of basic analytes, whereas, high pH tends to decrease retention of acidic species and increase retention of basic species.

Low pH (< 3) tends to improve peak tailing, especially for basic compounds due to the decrease in ionization of acidic silanol species on the stationary phase surface.

Figure 3: Surface silanol ionization.

Buffers are used to prevent pH changes, and it is important that the correct buffer system is used to prevent pH shifts (usually due to the introduction of the analyte in a diluent which does not match the mobile phase pH).  pH should be measured using a calibrated pH meter on the aqueous portion of the mobile phase only and accuracy to within ±0.05 pH units is recommended.  The actual mobile phase pH may alter significantly (typically 1 to 1.5 pH units closer to neutral) in the presence of larger amounts of organic modifier.  Mobile phase pH may alter on standing through the ingress of CO2 (making the mobile phase more acidic) and via evaporation of the organic portion when pre-mixed mobile phases are used.  The sensitivity of some detection systems (such as atmospheric pressure MS and fluorescence detection) may be affected by mobile phase pH changes which affect the degree of analyte ionization.

3. Void at Column Inlet

A void is caused by mechanical collapse of the stationary phase material which, under system pressure, compresses the bed materials, leaving a void at the head of the analytical column.

The void often results in loss of efficiency and poor peak shape (fronting, tailing, and shouldering are typical).

Voids are typically related to silica collapse which occurs under high pressure or high pH conditions.

Avoid pressure shock - increase flow (pressure) gradually (some modern pumps can be programmed to achieve this automatically) and use ‘make before break’ injection valves when possible.

Operate at pH < 7.5 where possible, unless your stationary phase has been designed for use at high pH.

It may be possible to temporarily fix the problem by running the column in the reversed direction and then return to the normal flow direction, however, the void will ultimately return after extended operation.

Figure 4: Peak shape recovery after column reversal to unblock an inlet frit or repair inlet void.

4. Large Extra Column Dead Volume

Extra column volume – the volume between the injection point and the detection point, excluding the part of the column containing the stationary phase.  It is composed of the injector, connecting lines, frits, and the detector; and it is this that determines the extra column effects.

Extra column effects – the total band broadening effects of all parts of the chromatographic system outside of the column itself.  Extra column effects must be minimized to maintain the efficiency of the column.  Areas of band broadening can include the injector, injection volume, connecting tubing, end fittings, frits, detector cell volume, and internal detector tubing.  The variances of all these contributions are additive.

W = bandwidth
The following are bandwidth contributions from
Wc = column
Ws = injector/autosampler
Wlc = lines and connectors
Wfc = detector flow cell

As long as the bandwidth contributions Ws, Wlc, and Wfc are each less than 1/3W their effect on W can be neglected.
There are many aspects of the system which add dead volume, leading to loss of efficiency and/or resolution (Figure 5 and 6) – typically these include:

  • Unnecessarily long tubing with i.d. larger than required
  • Incorrect fitting type or poorly made connection
  • Use of a guard column
  • Use of unnecessary unions within tubing
  • Large volume accessories or components (flow cell, injection loop etc.)

Therefore, using the correct fittings, minimizing tubing length and i.d., optimizing flow cell size for your instrument etc. will all help to reduce extra column volume.  Extra column volume is of particular importance when working with UHPLC applications.

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Figure 5: Effect of dead volume on HPLC resolution and separation.

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Figure 6: Effect of extra column volume on resolution and quantitation.

It is straightforward to measure the extra column volume of a system:

  • Remove the column and join the tubing with a zero-dead volume union
  • Inject 10 µL of 100% strong solvent (acetonitrile works with UV at 200 nm) or a solution of 1% acetone (monitor at 265 nm)
  • The apex retention time (tR) of the baseline perturbance due to the passage of the solvent gives the extra column hold up time of the system (expressed in minutes)
  • Multiply this time by the flow rate (in mL/min) to obtain the extra column volume (in mL)

5. Chelating Solute Interaction with Trace Metals in Base Silica

Trace metal content within or on the surface of the stationary phase material can chelate with certain analytes causing peak tailing (Figure 7).  The presence of surface metals can also increase silanol activity and interactions.

Surface silanol and metal moieties

Figure 7: Surface silanol and metal moieties.

When you are analyzing analytes, which are capable of chelation the following will help to mitigate any peak tailing effect:

  • Use high purity silica-based columns with low trace metal content
  • Add EDTA or another sacrificial chelating compound to the mobile phase which will be preferentially adsorbed to active sites to reduce analyte/stationary phase secondary interactions (and mitigate peak tailing effects)
  • Consider the use of polymeric phases or those known to contain low levels of metals likely to create tailing effects

As with any troubleshooting problem, approaching it in a logical fashion and only changing one thing at a time will help you to quickly resolve the issue.  An excellent troubleshooting tip is to have a bench marking method that is run on the system when it is fully functioning.  From this method parameters such s retention time, resolution, peak tailing etc. should all be assessed to give you normal values.  At the first sign of a problem, run the benchmarking method.  If this method works well then there is a problem with the particular analysis being run, if the benchmarking method fails then it is most likely the instrument which is at fault.  This will allow you to quickly focus on the correct part of the analysis, instrument or method, and will greatly reduce your troubleshooting time. 

Of course, don’t forget to use the CHROMacademy interactive troubleshooters too.

For more information on HPLC Troubleshooting watch our webcast - Effective HPLC Troubleshooting

 

You may also like...

Quick Guides

Why is pH Important for HPLC Buffers? »

HPLC Extra Column Volumes »

Chromatography Troubleshooting Tips »

Sample Diluent Effects in HPLC »

Webcasts and Tutorials

UHPLC Troubleshooting – How U is Your UHPLC? »

HPLC Troubleshooting Masterclass »

Troubleshooting Your HPLC Chromatogram – Selectivity, Resolution, and Baseline Issues »

loading data
loading data
loading data
loading data
loading data


Dr. Dawn Watson
 

This article was written by Dr. Dawn Watson.

Dawn received her PhD in synthetic inorganic chemistry from the University of Strathclyde, Glasgow. The focus of her PhD thesis was the synthesis and application of soft scorpionate ligands. As well as synthetic skills, this work relied on the use of a wide variety of analytical techniques, such as, NMR, mass spectrometry (MS), Raman spectroscopy, infrared spectroscopy (IR), UV-visible spectroscopy, electrochemistry, and thermogravimetric analysis.

Following her PhD she spent two years as a postdoctoral research fellow at Princeton University studying the reaction kinetics of small molecule oxidation by catalysts based on Cytochrome P450. In order to monitor these reactions stopped-flow kinetics, NMR, HPLC, GC-MS, and LC-MS techniques were utilized.

Prior to joining the Crawford Scientific and CHROMacademy technical team she worked for Gilson providing sales and support for the entire product range including, HPLC (both analytical and preparative), solid phase extraction, automated liquid handling, mass spec, pipettes, and laboratory consumables.

group  subsCHROMacademy can deliver to corporate clients on a multi-user subscription basis.
Served up from secure servers to the corporate intranet or individual desktops.

  • Microsite - your own learning site powered by CHROMacademy
  • Your Landing Pages -with your logo and branding
  • Customized Assessments - Based on content agreed upon Certificate of Completion
  • Certification Programs - Offer your learners a goal to strive towards
  • Our Learning Management System is S.C.O.R.M. compliant and will connect to your system
  • Engagement Package - E-newsletter stimulation program derived from your content and ours
  • Full archive of Essential Guide webcasts & tutorials
  • 1000’s of eLearning topics - HPLC / GC / Sample Prep / Mass Spec
  • Ask the Expert - our experts will answer your chromatography questions within 24 hrs.
  • Assessments - test your knowledge
  • Application notes & LCGC articles
  • Troubleshooting and virtual lab tools

Request a quote

 

 
 Home | About UsContact Us | SubscribeTerms and Conditions | Advertise | Privacy Policy 

  • loading data

loading data

loading data

 

loading data


loading data